How to Choose the Best Dog Frisbee: Buying Guide for Puppies, Active Dogs, and Seniors

Are you looking for a frisbee for your dog but not sure which one to buy? Along with the classic ball, the frisbee is one of the most popular toys for dogs. While it may seem like a simple item, choosing the ideal frisbee for your dog requires understanding some key characteristics.

When choosing a frisbee for your dog, it’s important to think about their comfort, safety, and how much they love to chew. Not all frisbees are created equal, and the material can make a big difference!

I’ve tested several dog frisbees with Mia, my German Shepherd x Malinois mix. Mia is full of energy—a powerful, agile, and intelligent combination that makes her the ultimate frisbee tester. Whether she’s sprinting to catch a high-flying disc or using her impressive jaw strength to chew, Mia puts every frisbee to the ultimate test.

To ensure we found the best options, we researched over fifty frisbees and selected five to test side-by-side. Dogs of all breeds and ages joined in, playing fetch, tugging, chewing, and sniffing to evaluate each frisbee’s durability, flight performance, versatility, and, most importantly, its “playability factor.”

If you’re considering a new disc toy for your pup, we’ve done the hard work so you don’t have to. Read on to find the perfect frisbee for your dog, whether they’re a gentle fetcher or a determined chewer like Mia!

The Cheapest Frisbees: Soft Silicone Flying Dyscs for Dogs

Soft silicone frisbees are the simplest and most affordable option, but that doesn’t make them any less effective. In fact, they’re Mia’s absolute favorite! They fly impressively far, are easy to handle, and have a soft, chew-friendly texture that dogs love. Most of these frisbees are quite similar, differing mainly in branding and designs, but they all perform equally well in terms of flight and durability.

Our Top Picks

The Best Dog Frisbees in 2025

KONG Flyer – A well-known brand from the USA

Key Features to look for when choosing the perfect frisbee for your dog

When you’re about to purchase a frisbee for your dog, it’s important to consider several features that will ensure not only fun but also safety and comfort for your pet. Here’s a breakdown of the key characteristics you should look for:

Durability: Choose a frisbee that can withstand bites
Dogs, especially active ones or those who tend to bite everything they see, like Mia, need a frisbee that can handle their bites and intense play sessions. Look for materials like natural rubber or high-durability plastic, known for their toughness. These materials are not only more resistant to wear but also can withstand rough use without breaking or warping quickly. This is crucial if your dog is a compulsive chewer or often plays in environments with hard surfaces.

• If you have a dog that tends to break toys quickly, opt for frisbees designed as “indestructible” or “for strong chewers”.

Safety: Non-toxic materials
Always ensure that the dog frisbee is made from non-toxic materials. Some plastics and rubbers may contain harmful chemicals like BPA or phthalates, which are detrimental to your pet’s health. Frisbees made from animal-safe certified materials ensure your dog won’t be exposed to harmful substances during play.

• Always look for frisbees labeled BPA-free, food-grade materials, or natural rubber as these are the safest for your dog.

Flexibility: A frisbee easy to grab
Flexible frisbees are ideal because they allow your dog to grab them easily without causing damage to their teeth or gums. A soft and flexible frisbee can be more comfortable for dogs, especially those still learning to play or those with sensitive teeth. Additionally, flexible frisbees are easier to transport and store.Tip: If you have a puppy or a senior dog, choose a frisbee that’s flexible enough for them to catch effortlessly.

Easy to Throw: Lightweight and aerodynamic
No matter how much experience you have throwing frisbees, it’s essential that the frisbee is lightweight and easy to throw. A well-designed frisbee should fly straight and maintain a good trajectory, making it easier to control and aim accurately. If the frisbee is too heavy or lacks good aerodynamic shape, it may be difficult for your dog to catch or for you to throw properly.

• Look for frisbees with an aerodynamic design, as these will allow them to fly steadily and predictably, even if you’re not experienced at throwing them.

Design for Puppies and Senior Dogs: Care for their teeth
Some frisbees are specifically designed for puppies or senior dogs with sensitive teeth. These frisbees are typically softer and less rigid, helping prevent damage to the dog’s teeth or gums. This is especially important if you have a young dog going through teething or an older dog with weakened teeth.

• If your dog is a puppy or a senior dog, look for frisbees designed especially for them. These are usually softer and tailored to meet their needs.

Water Resistance: Perfect for beach or pool play
If you like taking your dog to the beach or pool, a water-resistant frisbee could be perfect. Some frisbees are made from materials that not only float but are also easy to clean after getting wet. This is especially useful if you plan to play frisbee in water or damp areas, as it makes continued use and cleaning after each play session more manageable.

• If your dog loves water, look for frisbees designed to float. This will prevent the frisbee from sinking and being hard to retrieve.

Ensure the right fit for your dog
Dog frisbees come in various sizes to suit dogs of different breeds and sizes. A frisbee that is too large can be difficult for a small dog to handle, while a small frisbee may be ineffective for a larger dog. Be sure to choose a frisbee that matches your dog’s size, so they can catch it comfortably and enjoy the game.

• If you have a small or medium-sized dog, look for frisbees designed specifically for those breeds. For larger dogs, choose bigger and more durable frisbees.

Frisbees materials

Here’s a breakdown of the most common materials you’ll find in dog-friendly frisbees, along with tips to help you pick the right one.

Soft and Durable Rubber

This is a super popular choice for dog frisbees because it’s gentle on their teeth and gums, especially during those epic mid-air catches!

• Why it’s great: Rubber is flexible, bite-resistant, and safe for dogs who like to chew but don’t go overboard.
• Best for: Active dogs who love chasing and chewing but still need a material that’s gentle.
• Example: The KONG Flyer is a well-known rubber frisbee that many dog owners swear by—it’s soft, durable, and flies like a dream.

Lightweight Plastics

If your dog isn’t a heavy chewer, plastic frisbees can be a fantastic option. They’re lightweight, making them easier to throw long distances.

• Why it’s great: These frisbees are designed with rounded edges to keep your dog safe and are typically made from non-toxic materials.
• Best for: Dogs who enjoy a game of fetch but don’t chew on the frisbee between throws.
• Pro tip: Look for brands like Hyperflite Jawz, which create super tough plastics designed for dogs.

Soft Fabric or Nylon

Fabric frisbees are ideal for dogs with sensitive teeth or for younger pups and seniors. They’re also super easy to pack and carry.

• Why it’s great: Fabric and nylon frisbees are soft, lightweight, and great for indoor play or short-distance throws. Plus, they won’t hurt if they accidentally hit something (or someone).
• Best for: Puppies, older dogs, or indoor play sessions.
• Example: The Chuckit! Paraflight frisbee is an awesome fabric option that even floats on water—perfect for beach or pool days.

EVA Foam

Foam frisbees are a hidden gem for dogs who love to play fetch in the water. This material floats, is lightweight, and holds up well to regular use.

• Why it’s great: It’s soft and gentle on your dog’s mouth but still tough enough to last through many play sessions.
• Best for: Water-loving dogs or those who play fetch a lot.
• Example: The Ruffwear Hydro Plane is a crowd favorite for water games.

Eco-Friendly Options

If you’re looking for something better for the planet, some frisbees are made with biodegradable materials, like bamboo fiber blends or natural polymers.

• Why it’s great: They’re safe for your dog and leave a smaller footprint on the environment.
• Best for: Eco-conscious pet owners who want a sustainable option.

How to Choose the Right Frisbee for Your Dog’s Size and Energy Level

Here are some things to keep in mind:

• Chewing habits: If your dog’s a heavy chewer, go for tougher materials like rubber or foam.
• Size: Make sure the frisbee isn’t too big or too small for your dog to carry comfortably.
• Safety: Always choose materials that are non-toxic and designed specifically for dogs. Human frisbees can be too hard and might damage their teeth.
• Play style: If your dog loves water, a floating frisbee is a must!

You’ll typically find them available in three sizes:

• 15 cm: Ideal for small to medium-sized dogs.
• 18 cm: Perfect for larger breeds.
• 22 cm: Designed for extra-large dogs.

Pros and Cons of Playing Frisbee with Your Dog: Is It Really Good for Them?

Playing frisbee with your dog can be a fun and exciting activity for both of you. However, like any physical activity, it has its upsides and downsides.

Physical and Mental Benefits of Playing Frisbee

Physical Exercise
Frisbee is an exceptional way to keep your dog physically active. The running, jumping, and catching involved help burn off energy, build endurance, and strengthen core and leg muscles. Regular exercise like this not only keeps your dog in peak physical condition but can also extend their lifespan—active dogs have been found to live up to 2.5 years longer than their sedentary counterparts.

Mental Stimulation
But frisbee isn’t just about the body—it’s a workout for your dog’s brain, too. Engaging in this activity hones their focus, improves coordination, and sharpens problem-solving skills as they learn to anticipate and catch the disc mid-air. Plus, the shared playtime strengthens your bond, making your dog feel more confident, secure, and connected to you.

Agility Improvement
The dynamic movements of frisbee play also significantly enhance your dog’s agility and responsiveness. These skills are particularly useful if you’re training for competitive dog sports like flyball or agility courses, where speed, accuracy, and coordination are crucial.

Burns Excess Energy
For high-energy breeds like Malinois or Border Collies, frisbee is a lifesaver. A 20-minute frisbee session can work wonders in reducing pent-up energy, curbing boredom, and preventing destructive behaviors such as chewing, digging, or excessive barking. This makes it an ideal outlet for dogs that thrive on physical and mental challenges.

The Risks and Challenges of Playing Frisbee with Your Dog

Excessive Adrenaline
While it’s fun to see your dog excited, too much adrenaline can have downsides. Dogs may develop obsessive behaviors, constantly seeking high-intensity activities and becoming restless or stressed if they don’t get enough stimulation.

Joint and Muscle Strain
Jumping and sudden stops to catch the frisbee can put stress on your dog’s joints and muscles. Dogs prone to joint issues, like Labrador Retrievers or German Shepherds, are especially at risk. Over time, this can lead to conditions such as arthritis or hip dysplasia.

Risk of Injury
Playing on hard or uneven surfaces increases the likelihood of accidents. Dogs can trip, slip, or land awkwardly, leading to sprains, fractures, or muscle injuries.

Obsessive Behavior
Some dogs can become overly focused on the frisbee, leading to anxiety when the game ends. This “extreme athlete” mentality may cause them to push their limits, ignoring fatigue or discomfort.

How to Train Your Dog to Play Frisbee Like a Pro

Here’s a step-by-step guide on how to teach your dog to play frisbee, from beginner to competitive level, with professional tips for each step:

Step 1: Choose the Right Frisbee

• What to Do: Select a dog-safe frisbee made of soft, durable materials. For beginners or puppies, use lightweight, flexible frisbees to avoid injury.
• Why It Matters: Human frisbees can be too heavy or sharp, risking dental damage. A proper frisbee ensures safety and encourages positive interactions.
• Pro Tip for Competitors: Look for aerodynamic frisbees designed for distance and stability to help your dog learn accurate catches.

Step 2: Build Basic Commands

• What Your Dog Needs to Know: Ensure your dog has mastered basic obedience commands like “sit,” “stay,” “come,” and “drop it.” These are crucial for safe and controlled frisbee play.
• Training Method: Use treats or toys to reward compliance. Practice commands consistently before introducing the frisbee.
• Why It Matters: A well-trained dog is more focused and responsive during frisbee sessions.

Step 3: Introduce the Frisbee as a Toy

• What to Do: Let your dog sniff and explore the frisbee. Use it in tug-of-war games or roll it along the ground to spark their interest. Avoid throwing it right away.
• Why It Matters: This step creates a positive association with the frisbee, reducing fear or disinterest.
• Pro Tip for Competitors: Use verbal markers (like “yes!”) or a clicker when your dog interacts with the frisbee to build excitement for future training.

Step 4: Teach the Fetch Game

• What to Do: Start by rolling the frisbee along the ground. Encourage your dog to chase it and bring it back. Reward with treats or praise when they return the frisbee.
• Why It Matters: Rolling the frisbee is less intimidating than throwing it, helping your dog build confidence and understanding.
• Pro Tip: Use a second frisbee to trade during fetch if your dog struggles to release the first one.

Step 5: Practice Short Tosses

• What to Do: Toss the frisbee lightly a few feet away at your dog’s chest level. Encourage them to grab it mid-air, but don’t overdo the throws at first. Reward any successful attempts.
• Why It Matters: Gradual progression allows your dog to build confidence and learn how to time their jumps.
• Pro Tip for Competitors: Focus on consistent tosses in the same direction to develop accuracy and muscle memory for both you and your dog.

Step 6: Teach the Jump-and-Catch

• What to Do: Begin throwing the frisbee slightly higher to encourage your dog to jump. Use verbal commands like “catch” or “up” to signal the action.
• Why It Matters: Jumping for the frisbee requires coordination and timing. Start low to avoid straining their joints.
• Pro Tip for Competitors: Observe your dog’s natural jumping ability. For competitive play, work on controlled jumps to prevent unnecessary strain or injury.

Step 7: Build Stamina and Endurance

• What to Do: Gradually increase the number of throws per session. Monitor your dog for signs of fatigue and provide breaks with water and rest.
• Why It Matters: Frisbee is physically demanding. Overworking your dog can lead to exhaustion or injury.
• Pro Tip: Introduce interval training by mixing short sprints with longer throws to build both speed and endurance.

Step 8: Fine-Tune Precision and Commands

• What to Do: Teach advanced commands like “left,” “right,” or “wait” to guide your dog’s movements. Use consistent verbal cues paired with hand signals.
• Why It Matters: Precision training improves your dog’s ability to catch the frisbee consistently, especially for competitive play.
• Pro Tip for Competitors: Practice controlling the direction and height of your throws. Competitive judges look for precise, well-timed catches.

Step 9: Introduce Tricks and Disc Dog Routines

• What to Do: Teach your dog tricks like spinning, leaping off your back, or flipping before catching the frisbee. Incorporate these moves into a choreographed routine.
• Why It Matters: Tricks add flair to frisbee play and are essential for freestyle disc dog competitions.
• Pro Tip: Start with simple moves and build gradually. Use rewards to reinforce every new trick and ensure safety during more complex maneuvers.

Step 10: Compete or Enjoy Casual Play

• What to Do: If competing, research local disc dog events or organizations (like the USDAA or UpDog Challenge) and practice under similar conditions. If playing casually, keep sessions fun and varied to maintain your dog’s interest.
• Why It Matters: Whether for fun or competition, frisbee play strengthens your bond with your dog while keeping them healthy and happy.
• Pro Tip for Competitors: Video-record your practice sessions to analyze throws, catches, and routines for improvement.

Patience and consistency are key to teaching your dog frisbee skills. Celebrate every small victory, and never push your dog beyond their comfort level. With the right approach, your dog can enjoy this fun and rewarding activity, whether it’s in your backyard or on a competitive stage.

The Best Fenced Dog Parks in Melbourne for Frisbee

Playing frisbee with your dog is one of the most rewarding ways to bond, keep them active, and enjoy outdoor lifestyle. With Mia, our energetic Malinois, we’ve explored a variety of parks across the city of Melbourne—both fenced and unfenced. Here’s our list of the best spots to let your dog unleash their frisbee-catching skills, based on our personal adventures.

Fenced Parks for Dogs Who Love Frisbee

1. Clayton Reserve, North Melbourne
   A securely fenced triangular park perfect for off-leash frisbee fun. It’s equipped with water bowls and a sandpit, making it a top choice for dogs like Mia who love to dig and play.
2. Eades Dog Park, West Melbourne
   This cozy fenced area provides a safe space for Mia to socialize and practice catching frisbees without distractions.
3. Green Gully Reserve Fenced Dog Park, Keilor
   A spacious park with separate zones for small and large dogs. Ideal for practicing long frisbee throws.
4. Thomas Oval Dog Park
   Features agility courses and sensory play zones, making it a great choice for dogs who enjoy variety during their sessions.
5. Brooklyn Reserve Dog Park
   A fully fenced park with agility equipment and toys. We’ve spent hours here training Mia in a safe environment.
6. Brighton Beach Off-Leash Area
   While primarily a beach, this fenced section allows for safe play on sand, giving Mia a chance to burn off energy while enjoying the water.
7. Caulfield Racecourse Reserve
   It is another fantastic spot for dog owners in Melbourne, and it’s one Mia absolutely loves! This park offers a mix of open spaces and shaded areas, perfect for a frisbee session or just letting your dog explore and play with other dogs.
8. East Caulfield Reserve is a spacious park with a partially fenced area, ideal for dogs to run and play. The fenced section ensures safety, though it’s open on the side facing the rugby field. The reserve offers ample grassy spaces perfect for frisbee play and dog-friendly socializing, making it a great spot for active dogs like Mia.
   

Unfenced Parks for Frisbee Enthusiasts

1. Princes Park, Carlton North
   This vast, open park is perfect for long frisbee throws. While it’s unfenced, the expansive green spaces make it easy to keep an eye on your dog.
2. Fawkner Park, South Yarra
   With plenty of shade and wide-open areas, it’s an ideal spot for practicing frisbee with a well-trained dog.
3. Royal Park, Parkville
   Known for its natural beauty, this park offers large open fields where Mia can stretch her legs and chase frisbees to her heart’s content.
4. Yarra Bend Park, Fairfield
   A scenic park with sprawling green areas. The trails nearby are perfect for a post-frisbee cooldown walk.
5. Albert Park, South Melbourne
   This iconic spot offers vast grassy areas near the lake. Mia loves the open space and the occasional duck sighting!